| Platinum | Luna Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | BC's Pizza & Beer |
| Silver | Sunnyside Pizza |
| Bronze | Blaze Pizza |
| Top Pick | Marco's Pizza |
| Top Pick | More Than Pizza |
| Top Pick | Mountain Mike's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pieology Pizzeria Trading Post, Clovis |
| Top Pick | Pizza Factory |
| Top Pick | Windmill NY Pizzeria |